Art Law & Cultural HeritagePeeters Law · Antwerp – Brussels

I.

The field

A work of art is at once a movable good, the expression of an author, an asset within an estate and, at times, part of the cultural heritage of a community or a state. Each of those characterisations brings its own body of rules.

Property law, contract law, copyright, succession law, tax law and public heritage law therefore meet in a single object. In many matters several of them apply at the same time, and the decisive question does not always lie in the area of law in which the matter first presents itself.

Art matters are also frequently international. A work may be created in one country, sold at auction in a second, held by a collector resident in a third and claimed by heirs or by a state elsewhere. Which court has jurisdiction, which law governs the transfer of ownership, and whether an export licence, a contract or a judgment will have effect in another state are then questions of private international law.

Peeters Law is a Belgian legal practice that approaches art-related matters from that intersection: between art and private international law, contracts, inheritance, intellectual property and wealth planning. The practice offers legal analysis, contractual assistance and international coordination to those who create, hold, trade, preserve or exhibit works of art.

II.

Legal services

Within this field, the practice assists on the following matters:

  1. Art acquisition, sales and ownership disputes. Title to works of art; the acquisition of movables in good faith; the law of the place where the work is situated at the time of transfer; claims for recovery; and disputes between buyers, sellers, co-owners and heirs.
  2. Art transactions, gallery agreements and auction contracts. Drafting, reviewing and negotiating contracts of sale, consignment agreements, representation agreements between artists and galleries, commission and agency arrangements and the conditions of sale of auction houses, including warranties, guarantees and the allocation of risk.
  3. Authenticity, provenance and restitution of artworks. The legal consequences of attribution, certificates of authenticity and catalogues raisonnés; provenance due diligence; the position of the parties where a work proves not to be authentic; and claims for the return or restitution of works, including questions arising from the Nazi era or from the colonial past.
  4. Copyright, artists' rights and intellectual property. Economic and moral rights of artists; the resale right; the reproduction and licensing of images of works; the use of an artist's name, signature or trade mark; and the exploitation of works across borders.
  5. Art collections, inheritance and estate planning. The place of works of art in a succession and in a matrimonial property regime; gifts and wills relating to works or collections; the transfer of a collection to the next generation; the European Succession Regulation in estates connected with several countries; and, in coordination with tax specialists, regimes such as payment of inheritance tax in works of art.
  6. Cultural heritage protection and regulatory compliance. The rules of the Belgian Communities on the protection of movable cultural heritage; international instruments such as the 1970 UNESCO Convention; and the compliance obligations of art market participants, notably in respect of anti-money-laundering rules and due diligence on counterparties and on the origin of works.
  7. Cross-border movement, import and export of artworks. Export licences for cultural goods under Regulation (EC) No 116/2009; the introduction and import of cultural goods under Regulation (EU) 2019/880; the return of cultural objects unlawfully removed from the territory of a Member State under Directive 2014/60/EU; and temporary movements for exhibitions, loans and restoration.
  8. Art insurance, professional liability and disputes. Insurance of works and collections, including during transport and loans; claims following damage, loss or theft; the liability of experts, appraisers, restorers, transporters, galleries and auction houses; and assistance in negotiation, mediation, arbitration and court proceedings.
  9. Art foundations, private collections and cultural organisations. Structuring the holding and management of a collection, including through a private foundation, a public-benefit foundation or a non-profit association under the Belgian Code of Companies and Associations; statutes and governance; deposit and loan arrangements; and the continuity of a collection beyond its founder.
  10. Legal advice concerning museums, galleries, artists and collectors. The legal relationships between those actors: loan and exhibition agreements, acquisitions and donations to institutions, commissions of new works, cooperation and sponsorship agreements, and the legal aspects of the day-to-day activity of artists, galleries and collectors.
III.

For whom

Questions in this field may concern, among others:

  • Artists and their estates — agreements with galleries and commissioning parties, copyright and the resale right, and the management of a body of work after the artist's death.
  • Private collectors and art investors — acquisitions and sales, verification of title and provenance, insurance and the long-term holding of works.
  • Galleries and auction houses — the contractual framework with artists, consignors and buyers, conditions of sale, compliance and disputes.
  • Museums and cultural institutions — acquisitions, donations, loans, exhibitions, restitution requests and heritage rules.
  • Art foundations and non-profit cultural organisations — incorporation, statutes, governance and the relationship between founder, foundation and collection.
  • Families holding international art collections — a collection located in, or connected with, several countries, its place within the estate and its transfer to the next generation.
IV.

Approach

In art-related matters, as elsewhere in the practice, the first task is to identify the question that truly lies within the situation. A dispute over a painting may prove to be a question of the law applicable to ownership; a question about a gallery agreement may prove to concern copyright; a planned donation to a museum may raise questions of succession, tax and export at the same time.

The practice provides:

  • Legal analysis — characterising the matter, determining jurisdiction and applicable law, and identifying the relevant rules of Belgian, European and international law, including the Belgian Code of Private International Law.
  • Contractual assistance — drafting, reviewing and negotiating the agreements through which works are bought, sold, consigned, lent, insured, reproduced or transferred.
  • International coordination — working with lawyers and advisers in other jurisdictions so that a matter connected with several countries is handled coherently.

Questions of attribution, valuation and condition are in the first place matters for art historians, experts, appraisers, provenance researchers and conservators. Where a matter requires such expertise, or specific tax or local legal advice, that is brought in without losing sight of the coherence of the matter.

Advice can be given in Dutch, French, English, German and Spanish.

V.

Consultation

A question concerning a work of art, a collection, an artist's estate or a cultural institution can be put to Peeters Law at info@peeterslaw.com. Consultations are possible in Antwerp, Brussels or online.

Request a consultation

Or use the contact form.

Your Legal Enquiry on this subject · All legal practice areas · Search Legal Topics

← Back to Professional Practice

↑