Peeters Law · Laboratorium · Working Paper II

The Situs Problem

Art Collections, Artists’ Estates and the Limits of Fiscal Territoriality

EditionThis is the expanded edition of Working Paper II, written in English, which is its principal language. It supersedes the first edition, Art Collections, Cross-Border Donations and the Legal Significance of Location. The first edition remains available in its original Dutch text and in its English translation, both unchanged.

Peeters Law · Laboratorium · Working Paper II

THE SITUS PROBLEM

Art Collections, Artists’ Estates and the Limits of Fiscal Territoriality

Artistic Value, Cross-Border Succession and the Preservation of Cultural Heritage

Author
Karen-Anne Peeters
Series
Peeters Law · Laboratorium · Working Paper II
Edition
Expanded English research manuscript · 15 November 2026
Status
Working Paper – Research in Progress. Independent research by the author; not peer-reviewed and not published elsewhere.

Working Paper – Research in ProgressThis working paper is a publicly accessible research contribution. Certain legal interpretations and comparative tax questions remain subject to further verification, as identified in the text. It does not constitute individual legal or tax advice. The verification status of each proposition is set out in section XII.

This working paper is an independent legal research contribution. It examines comparative legal frameworks and unresolved questions concerning art succession, cultural heritage and cross-border taxation. It does not constitute individual legal or tax advice.

Abstract

When the transmission of art threatens its preservation

A work of art may represent considerable economic value without its owner possessing liquid assets corresponding to that value. The difficulty becomes particularly apparent upon death. An artist may leave an extensive body of work whose market value becomes evident only after death. A collector may have assembled, over several decades, a collection that is not merely an economic asset but a historically, artistically and personally coherent whole.

When heirs become liable for inheritance tax on such assets, the resulting obligation may compel the sale of the very works they have inherited. Tax law treats the collection as property capable of valuation; cultural preservation may depend upon its remaining intact. European legal systems respond in markedly different ways. Some facilitate lifetime transfers. Others grant conditional relief for culturally important property or allow works of art to be accepted in satisfaction of inheritance-tax liabilities.

The Spanish Autonomous Community of Madrid provides substantial relief for certain gifts and inheritances between close relatives: a reduction of 99 per cent of the calculated tax liability may apply. Can a Belgian artist or collector obtain that relief merely by moving an art collection to a Madrid storage facility? More fundamentally, what is the significance of an artwork’s physical location where the owner, beneficiary and legal connecting factors are spread across several jurisdictions?

This paper examines the physical location of art, its civil-law transfer, international fiscal connecting factors and the public interest in preserving cultural heritage. It advances a hypothesis rather than a tax-planning proposition:

Relocating an artwork may change one territorial connecting factor without displacing the legal and fiscal consequences attached to other connecting factors.

A sustainable approach to the transmission of art must therefore consider property law, private international law, lifetime gifts, succession taxation, artists’ rights and cultural preservation together.

Keywords: Art Law; Cultural Heritage; Private International Law; Succession; Gift Tax; Lex Rei Sitae; Art Collections; Madrid; Estate Planning; Comparative Law.

I.The Paradox of the Artistic Estate

Inheritance taxation generally begins with an apparently simple assumption: property left at death has an ascertainable value which can form the basis of a tax assessment. In the case of liquid assets, the difference between valuation and ability to pay may be limited. In art, it may be decisive.

A painting valued at €500,000 will not necessarily realise that sum if sold at short notice. Its price may depend on authentication, provenance, physical condition, market timing, the artist’s reputation and a comparatively small pool of potential purchasers. Selling one work may also affect the historical coherence or economic attractiveness of the remaining collection.

Heirs may thus face a double constraint. They must discharge a tax liability calculated by reference to the inherited property’s assessed value, yet the measures taken to raise the money may destroy the family or cultural project the deceased wanted to transmit.

Fiscal recognition of art’s economic value may cause the loss of the artwork itself.

This is not merely a question of favourable tax treatment. It concerns the relationship between individual property, the rights of heirs and the wider public interest in preserving cultural heritage. The apparent conflict becomes sharper once the art crosses borders and several legal systems attach different consequences to the same objects.

II.Two Estates That Are Not Legally Identical

A. The artist’s estate

Imagine an artist who dies leaving two hundred original works in a studio. Some have been exhibited; others are on consignment with galleries; many have never been offered for sale. The estate may also contain preparatory drawings, digital files, archives, contractual claims, reproduction rights and copyright.

Such an estate is not necessarily a collection of privately owned movable objects in the ordinary sense. An initial legal inventory must determine which works belong to the artist’s private patrimony, which are associated with a professional activity, whether particular works are stock, and how gallery and consignment contracts affect possession and ownership. A stated gallery price is not, without more, the price the estate could realise, still less automatically the correct figure for every fiscal purpose.

Physical ownership must also be distinguished from intellectual property. Acquiring a painting does not automatically entail acquiring the copyright in the underlying artistic work. The right to display, reproduce or license a work may depend on separate rules and agreements.

Who is to administer the artistic estate? Who may approve exhibitions, reproductions or a catalogue raisonné? How should previously unsold work be valued? How can the archive and body of work be kept together without unfairly prejudicing particular heirs?

A lifetime foundation or another governance structure may help, but its creation is not itself a tax exemption. Contributions of artworks, governance, operational costs, fiscal consequences and compliance obligations must be examined separately.

B. The collector’s estate

A private collector may have acquired works over decades through purchase, gift or inheritance. Each work is a distinct asset, yet the collection may have acquired an identity as an ensemble. One child may wish to preserve it; another may seek an economically equivalent share of the estate.

The planning problem therefore extends beyond the tax on succession. It may involve reserved shares, the treatment of lifetime gifts, valuation, management, custody, insurance, loans to museums and the possibility that works will be sold after the transfer.

A gift that limits inheritance tax may still generate family disputes. Conversely, a solution that keeps the collection together may involve greater expense or restrictions on freedom of disposal.

The fiscally cheapest solution is not necessarily the best succession arrangement or the best solution for cultural preservation.

III.The Different Legal Functions of an Artwork’s Location

The situs of tangible movable property appears to be a concrete matter: a painting is in Antwerp, Paris or Madrid. Yet location can perform different functions in different legal rules.

1. Physical location

Location matters for storage, transport, insurance, conservation and potentially for public-law controls. Sending a painting to a professional warehouse in Madrid is a verifiable event. It does not itself transfer title to another person.

2. Proprietary location and transfer

The law applicable to the ownership and transfer of movable assets must be identified under the relevant private-international-law rules. A donation agreement, the acceptance of a gift, any required mode of delivery and the proprietary effects of the transaction are separate questions. A deposit agreement ordinarily establishes custody; it does not by itself prove that the depositor’s child has become owner.

Where a third-party custodian continues holding the object after a purported gift, both the evidence of transfer and the applicable proprietary rules require particular attention.

3. Fiscal connecting factors

Gift and inheritance taxes may attach to the donor’s or deceased’s fiscal residence, the beneficiary’s residence, the location of assets, the form of an instrument or a combination of factors. The same transaction may thus fall within the taxing jurisdiction of more than one country.

Fiscal territoriality is not automatically equivalent to the proprietary principle of lex rei sitae. Even where two rules employ a geographical concept, they need not assign it the same function.

4. Cultural and regulatory location

Heritage protection, export controls, provenance requirements and restitution claims may apply to an artwork independently of its owner’s fiscal residence. Moving it does not necessarily extinguish such constraints.

An artwork has one physical location at a given moment, but it may carry several legally relevant connecting factors.

IV.The Flemish Model: Lifetime Gifts and Payment in Kind

A. Registered lifetime gifts

Flanders generally levies gift tax at 3 per cent on registered gifts of movable assets between relatives in the direct line and between partners, subject to the applicable conditions. Assuming an entirely qualifying privately held collection worth €1 million, the ordinary calculation would yield €30,000 in Flemish gift tax.

After a legally effective transfer, ownership of the donated works no longer belongs to the donor. Civil-law consequences may nevertheless remain relevant to the later settlement of the donor’s estate, including rules protecting reserved heirs and dealing with previous gifts.

Where the objects are professional stock, or where valuable rights other than the physical artworks are included, a separate tax and civil-law assessment is necessary.

B. Unregistered gifts

Some tangible movable goods can be transferred by an effective manual gift without compulsory registration. Where no registration occurs, no gift tax is ordinarily charged at that stage. For new unregistered gifts made on or after 1 January 2025, the Flemish fiscal risk period is five years. If the donor dies within the relevant period, inheritance tax may still become payable on the gifted property; if the donor survives it, the gifted value may remain outside Flemish inheritance taxation.

The legal effectiveness and evidence of the donation are indispensable. A painting that remains in the donor’s residence, or in a gallery or warehouse under the donor’s continuing arrangements, presents evidentiary and possibly substantive difficulties. An inventory or signed confirmation may support proof; it cannot cure the absence of a legally effective transfer.

C. Cultural objects accepted in payment of inheritance tax

Since 1 July 2023, Flanders has offered a distinct mechanism under which eligible cultural objects can be accepted in payment of inheritance-tax liabilities and relevant related amounts. The regime is directed towards cultural property meeting specified criteria, including certain major works and culturally significant objects; acceptance is not automatic.

For the purpose of payment in kind, accepted property can be credited at 120 per cent of its established market value. Thus a qualifying work assessed at €500,000 may, if accepted, count for €600,000 towards the amount payable. That enhanced payment credit is not automatically the artwork’s taxable value in the estate.

An advance assessment may be requested during the prospective deceased’s lifetime. Under relevant conditions, objects physically situated abroad may also be considered. The precise conditions, decision-making process and destination of the works must be examined in the individual case.

This mechanism does not simply exempt the heirs from tax. It involves acceptance and transfer of the relevant cultural assets into public ownership.

A lifetime gift seeks to remove transferred art from a later taxable estate; payment in kind uses art to satisfy inheritance taxation.

The former may keep the collection within the family. The latter may secure its conservation for a wider public.

V.The Madrid Model: Relief of 99 Per Cent of the Calculated Tax

The Autonomous Community of Madrid offers substantial relief for certain gifts and inheritances between close relatives. Subject to the relevant legislative and formal conditions, a bonificación of 99 per cent of the calculated Spanish gift or inheritance-tax liability may apply to qualifying transfers between parents and children.

Describing this as a tax of 1 per cent of the collection’s value is incorrect. If the otherwise calculated Spanish tax is €100,000, relief of 99 per cent may leave €1,000 payable. That is 1 per cent of the calculated tax, not 1 per cent of the market value of the donated artworks.

A. A genuine Madrid connection

Where the relevant personal and territorial connecting rules genuinely point to Madrid, the relief may materially change the tax cost of transferring an art collection to a child. Gifts and successions must nevertheless be considered separately, and the conditions of the applicable regional regime must be met. A reference to residence in Madrid, without analysing the full statutory connecting rules, is not enough to establish the result.

B. A Belgian collection sent to storage in Madrid

Consider a Flemish tax resident who owns a valuable private collection and wishes to give it to an adult child who also resides in Belgium. The owner transports the works to a professional depot in Madrid and proposes to execute a Spanish notarial gift.

Spanish law may establish a territorial connection for movable assets located on Spanish territory. For particular gifts received by non-resident beneficiaries, the legislation contains rules identifying the autonomous community whose legislation may be applied. An important connecting factor looks to the autonomous community where the movable property was situated for the largest number of days during the preceding five years.

This does not necessarily mean that every work must have been in Madrid continuously for five full years. But it also does not mean that a newly imported painting will automatically qualify for Madrid relief. The application of the five-year rule where the works spent part, or most, of the reference period outside Spain requires further examination of the law, administrative interpretation and the facts.

Open research question: How is the five-year location test applied where a collection has only recently been brought into Spain from Belgium?

A definitive answer should not be inferred merely from general webpages describing the Madrid bonificación.

C. The Belgian registration counterweight

Belgian law has required the registration of qualifying foreign notarial instruments recording gifts of movable assets by Belgian residents since 15 December 2020. Article 19, first paragraph, 6°, of the Belgian Code of Registration, Mortgage and Court Registry Duties provides the statutory basis.

For a donor fiscally resident in Flanders, a qualifying Spanish notarial gift may therefore trigger Flemish gift tax. Moving the paintings to Madrid does not, by itself, change the donor’s fiscal residence or remove the Belgian registration rule.

It is consequently possible for the Spanish relief to reduce an otherwise due Spanish gift tax while Flemish gift tax remains payable as well. Executing a deed in Madrid is not in itself an escape from Belgian gift taxation.

D. An inheritance rather than a lifetime gift

A Flemish tax resident who dies owning paintings held in Spain may in principle leave those paintings within a worldwide estate subject to Flemish inheritance tax. Spain may also claim inheritance tax by reason of the Spanish location of the property. The Spanish regional connecting rules governing succession are not identical to those governing gifts.

The Flemish Tax Code includes a provision, Article 2.7.5.0.4, addressing relief in respect of foreign inheritance tax on foreign property, under applicable conditions. Its possible operation must be analysed in the specific facts; it is not a general credit for all foreign gift taxes.

Madrid’s relief may lower the Spanish tax but does not necessarily extinguish the Flemish assessment.

E. The artist’s professional assets

A transfer of art held as business stock, rather than a private collection, may have consequences for income tax, VAT, business valuation and the cessation or transfer of a professional activity. Potential taxation of gains at the level of the donor also requires jurisdiction-specific examination. Madrid’s gift-tax relief cannot serve as a substitute for that broader analysis.

VI.Comparative Law: Four Different Models

The problems of artistic succession are not addressed exclusively through reduced inheritance-tax rates. At least four distinct models emerge.

Model I. Lifetime transmission

The essential mechanism is an effective transfer during life. Flemish registered and unregistered gifts illustrate two different combinations of certainty, immediate tax cost and exposure to subsequent inheritance taxation.

In the United Kingdom, certain lifetime gifts can fall outside inheritance tax where the donor survives seven years, subject to the particular statutory rules. A gift with reservation of benefit may prevent that result where the donor continues to enjoy the donated object in a manner caught by the legislation. A collector cannot assume that signing a gift document while keeping unrestricted enjoyment of the painting necessarily removes it from the relevant taxable estate.

Model II. Conditional relief for cultural preservation

Germany provides exemptions under § 13(1)(2) of the Erbschaftsteuer- und Schenkungsteuergesetz for qualifying art and collections. Depending on the applicable requirements, a partial exemption of 60 per cent or, under stricter conditions, full relief may be available. Preservation, public interest, family ownership or heritage status may be relevant, as may the consequences of disposal during the statutory period.

Ireland provides an exemption for certain heritage property of national, scientific, historical or artistic interest, subject to conditions that can include keeping the objects in Ireland, reasonable public access and the absence of trading purposes.

The United Kingdom’s Conditional Exemption may also be available for qualifying heritage assets, generally in exchange for undertakings about conservation and access.

The conceptual exchange is striking: the state forgoes an immediate fiscal claim because the owner assumes obligations serving cultural preservation.

Model III. Art accepted in payment of inheritance tax

The Netherlands provides a scheme by which qualifying cultural objects may be transferred to the State in satisfaction of inheritance tax. Depending on the statutory requirements, the relevant credit can be calculated by reference to 120 per cent of the assessed value, subject to limits.

France’s dation en paiement, under Article 1716 bis of the Code général des impôts, allows certain culturally important objects to be proposed in payment of specified tax liabilities, including succession duties. The United Kingdom has an Acceptance in Lieu mechanism.

These regimes address liquidity and public preservation, but they frequently entail surrendering family ownership of the particular works accepted.

Model IV. Favourable personal or territorial tax regimes

Madrid represents a fourth approach: where the statutory connecting factors and relief conditions apply, the tax due on a qualifying family transfer may be substantially reduced.

Portugal presents another, different example. Under its stamp-duty framework, qualifying gratuitous transfers to spouses, descendants and ascendants can benefit from an exemption. Yet placing Belgian-owned artworks in Portugal does not, without more, eliminate the donor’s or deceased’s Belgian tax connections.

The United States provides a further comparison. The federal estate and gift tax framework includes a substantial basic exclusion amount for 2026, but residence, citizenship, domicile, situs, state taxes and other facts can alter the analysis. An American comparison cannot be reduced to the headline exclusion amount.

These models are not equivalent. Some operate through timing, others through public-interest obligations, transfer to the state or residence- and situs-based tax rules.

VII.Preserving the Collection: A Different Objective from Saving Tax

The comparison reveals a tension commonly obscured by the language of tax efficiency. A favourable result may require the owner to relinquish something valuable besides money.

A lifetime gift reduces the donor’s ownership or enjoyment. A heritage exemption may impose obligations concerning conservation and public access. Payment in kind transfers artworks into public hands. A residence-based tax regime may depend upon genuine personal and territorial circumstances that cannot simply be asserted by moving objects.

A family wishing to retain a collection intact requires a different structure from heirs who wish to place an artist’s legacy permanently within a museum. In some cases the objective is the lowest possible tax; in others it is the continuity of the collection, the protection of all heirs, or public access to works of cultural significance.

The legal strategy should identify these objectives before choosing an instrument. The most favourable nominal tax treatment is not necessarily the most favourable outcome for the collection.

VIII.The Private-International-Law Questions Behind the Tax Answer

A. Title and evidence

A meaningful collection inventory must establish ownership of each work, acquisition history, third-party rights and any relevant contractual restrictions. Gallery consignments, museum loans, storage and conservation agreements cannot be treated as interchangeable.

A purported cross-border gift requires independent analysis of the applicable law, validity, acceptance, the proprietary effect of transfer and any delivery requirements. Where custody remains with a third party, the evidential arrangements matter.

B. Succession law and its limits

Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 provides a framework for aspects of cross-border succession, including applicable law. It does not harmonise inheritance taxes, and fiscal matters fall outside its scope. It also requires careful differentiation between succession questions and dispositions made during lifetime.

Choosing the law applicable to succession is not the same as electing the inheritance-tax system with the lowest rates.

C. Valuation

Market value may vary with purpose and context: insurance, sale, lifetime gift, inheritance or acceptance in payment of tax. An artist’s professional stock, an established collector’s holdings and an integrated ensemble may raise different questions. The valuation methodology must be appropriate to the legal operation; market quotations are not automatically definitive fiscal values.

D. Cultural heritage and international movement

Protected cultural objects may be subject to licensing, export controls, provenance requirements and public-law restrictions. Some works cannot be moved freely merely because the private owner wishes to alter their situs. Tax planning must not be detached from the legal conditions governing the movement of cultural property.

IX.The Situs Problem as an Experiment in Legal Characterisation

1. The hypothesis: can the location of art determine its fiscal destiny?

The preceding analysis has identified several legal systems capable of attributing consequences to the transmission of artworks.

The question is whether these consequences can be understood through a single dominant connecting factor: the physical location of the property.

Consider the following hypothesis.

A Flemish tax resident owns a valuable private art collection. The collection is transferred to a professional storage facility in Madrid. The owner subsequently proposes to donate the works to an adult child who remains fiscally resident in Belgium, using a Spanish notarial instrument.

The apparent solution relies upon Madrid’s favourable regime for certain family transfers.

Yet several questions remain unresolved.

Does the location of the collection establish a sufficient Spanish territorial connection? Does it determine the applicable autonomous-community legislation? Does the Spanish instrument trigger Belgian registration and gift taxation? Has ownership been effectively transferred? And will the arrangement preserve the collection in accordance with the family’s actual intentions?

The experiment tests a central methodological proposition:

A legal solution constructed around one connecting factor may fail because other legally relevant connecting factors have been excluded from the initial characterisation of the problem.

The seven-part Peeters Law framework provides a means of examining that proposition.

T — Territorial Context

The initial characterisation presents the transaction as a donation of artworks situated in Madrid.

That description is factually plausible but legally incomplete.

The physical location of the works provides one possible connection to Spanish taxation. The donor’s continuing fiscal residence in Flanders supplies another connection, relevant to Belgian registration and gift-tax obligations.

The beneficiary’s residence, the location history of the works and the legal form of the transaction introduce additional territorial questions.

The legal analysis must therefore distinguish between:

  • The geographical location of the artworks.
  • The territorial reach of Spanish gift taxation.
  • The autonomous-community rules governing the applicable regional regime.
  • The Belgian fiscal consequences of a donation by a Belgian resident.
  • The applicable rules governing the transfer of ownership.

The territorial dimension does not designate a single controlling jurisdiction.

It reveals that different legal systems may attach different consequences to the same transfer.

First result: the relocation to Madrid may alter a territorial connection without necessarily displacing the existing Belgian connection.

M — Substantive Legal Fields

The apparent question concerns tax reduction.

The underlying transaction, however, engages several legal fields.

Gift taxation must be distinguished from the civil-law validity of the donation. The transfer of title must be distinguished from physical custody. The treatment of lifetime gifts must be distinguished from the subsequent settlement of the donor’s estate.

Cultural heritage restrictions may affect the movement or destination of particular works independently of the fiscal structure.

If the collection consists of works retained by their creator as professional stock, business taxation and intellectual-property rights may introduce further considerations.

The material dimension therefore exposes a second possible error: treating a fiscal advantage as if it established the legal suitability of the transaction as a whole.

Second result: a transaction may be fiscally favourable within one regime while remaining legally or economically unsuitable when its other consequences are examined.

N — Normative Structure

The relevant rules do not necessarily pursue the same objectives.

The Madrid tax relief reflects legislative choices concerning particular family transfers.

The Belgian registration regime determines when certain foreign notarial donations are brought within Belgian taxation.

Succession law protects legally recognised family entitlements. Cultural heritage legislation may seek to preserve objects of public significance.

These objectives can coexist without forming a single normative hierarchy.

The application of Madrid’s tax relief does not establish the inapplicability of Belgian legislation. Equally, the existence of Belgian tax obligations does not invalidate the Spanish regime.

A simultaneous application of different tax rules is not necessarily a contradiction within either legal system.

Third result: the relevant problem may be one of overlapping statutory scopes rather than a conflict requiring one rule to prevail over another.

C — Language and Legal Culture

The terminology used to describe the proposed transaction may itself conceal legal assumptions.

The term situs suggests an ascertainable physical location.

But physical location, fiscal territoriality and the applicable law governing proprietary effects do not necessarily refer to the same legal concept.

Similarly, a Spanish donación executed through a documento público does not, merely because of its form, settle every question concerning Belgian taxation or the proprietary effects of the transaction.

Madrid’s bonificación del 99 por ciento must not be confused with a tax amounting to 1% of the value of the donated collection.

The expression tax residence must also be distinguished from ownership, physical presence and the location of an asset.

Fourth result: the apparent simplicity of the proposed arrangement partly depends upon treating legally distinct concepts as interchangeable.

S — Strategic Dimension

The strategic question must now be reformulated.

The initial objective was expressed as obtaining favourable taxation by moving the collection.

But what does the owner actually wish to achieve?

If the objective is merely to transfer the artworks to a child at a predictable fiscal cost, a registered Flemish gift may deserve comparison.

If the owner is considering an effective unregistered manual gift, the applicable inheritance-tax risk period and the evidence of transfer become central.

If the objective is preserving culturally significant works for the public, the Flemish payment-in-kind mechanism or other heritage arrangements may be relevant.

If the owner wishes to keep the collection within the family, an arrangement requiring transfer into public ownership may not correspond to that objective.

If the family is genuinely established across several jurisdictions, an international structure may require a more comprehensive analysis of residence, succession and ownership.

The Madrid proposal should therefore be compared with available alternatives, rather than treated as the presumptively preferred solution.

Fifth result: the appropriate strategy follows from the legally defined objective; it cannot be established by the attractiveness of one tax provision alone.

Σ — The Heyvaertian Fault Line

The analytical fault line appears where the apparent unity of the transaction begins to break down.

The artworks are situated in Madrid.

The proposed donation is executed before a Spanish notary.

The donor nevertheless remains fiscally resident in Flanders.

The transaction may consequently engage a Spanish territorial rule while also falling within the Belgian regime governing qualifying foreign notarial gifts.

Nothing in the physical relocation itself establishes that the Belgian fiscal connection has ceased to exist.

The difficulty is not that one legal system necessarily contradicts another.

Rather, the initial construction of the problem has allowed one legally relevant fact to dominate the analysis.

The artwork is in Madrid; therefore Madrid determines the taxation of its transfer.

The first proposition may be factually correct.

The second does not follow without further legal justification.

The fault line lies precisely in that transition.

Sixth result: the apparent solution depends upon an inference between geographical location and fiscal exclusivity that the relevant legal rules do not automatically support.

Ω — Reflexive Observation

The final inquiry examines the construction of the legal question itself.

Why did the investigation begin with the location of the collection?

The initial formulation assumed that a change in the location of the asset was the principal route towards the desired legal consequence.

That assumption directed attention towards Spanish taxation before the donor’s continuing Belgian tax position, the nature of the property and the family’s broader objectives had been examined.

A different formulation may produce a different legal investigation.

Instead of asking:

Can the collection be donated in Madrid under a favourable tax regime?

One might ask:

How can ownership of the collection be transferred in a manner that is legally effective, fiscally coherent across the relevant jurisdictions and consistent with the owner’s intentions concerning preservation and succession?

This question does not presume that Madrid is irrelevant.

It places Madrid within the wider configuration of legally available solutions.

The reflexive inquiry thus reveals that the original question was not neutral.

It already contained an assumption about the legal significance of location.

Seventh result: the initial characterisation of the problem may be more consequential than the selection of the legal rule subsequently applied.

2. Testing the analytical result

The framework should not be credited with explanatory value merely because it has generated seven observations.

Its usefulness must be assessed against the alternative of careful conventional legal analysis.

Three variations can help test the result.

Variation A — The collection remains in Belgium

If the artworks never leave Belgium, the proposed Spanish territorial connection may not arise. The Belgian donor’s fiscal residence, however, remains unchanged.

This comparison helps distinguish the legal consequences attributable to the location of the art from those attributable to the donor’s personal position.

Variation B — The works move to Madrid, but ownership is not transferred

The geographical connecting factor changes, while the donor remains owner.

The situation may generate questions of storage, insurance, heritage regulation or taxation connected with the presence of the assets, but the physical movement is not itself a gift.

This variation isolates the distinction between relocation and donation.

Variation C — The owner’s principal objective is cultural preservation

Suppose that the owner wishes to ensure that the collection remains intact and accessible to future generations.

A scheme involving public cultural institutions may then deserve consideration even if it does not minimise taxation to the same extent as another available route.

The characterisation of the problem changes from fiscal optimisation to intergenerational preservation.

The legally relevant comparison changes with it.

These variations demonstrate the framework’s possible contribution: it makes the consequences of changing one factual or legal premise visible without assuming that all other premises change simultaneously.

3. What would show that the method adds nothing?

The method must remain open to criticism.

Its seven parts do not establish an independent source of law. They do not replace statutory interpretation, conflict-of-laws rules, fiscal analysis or the examination of relevant case law.

A careful conventional analysis of Belgian and Spanish taxation may identify precisely the same problems without employing this framework.

If it does so with equal clarity and economy, the seven-part method has added little.

The method is useful only to the extent that it makes legally consequential assumptions more explicit, exposes premature characterisations or permits a more disciplined comparison of competing legal routes.

In the present experiment, its possible contribution is not the discovery of a new tax rule.

It is the identification of an earlier analytical error: the assumption that the physical relocation of an artwork can be treated as the relocation of all legal consequences associated with its transmission.

4. Provisional methodological conclusion

The experiment does not establish that a Madrid-based arrangement can never be appropriate.

Nor does it establish that the seven-part framework is necessary for every international art transaction.

It illustrates a more limited proposition.

Where different legal systems employ distinct connecting factors, the selection of one geographical fact as the organising principle of the analysis may conceal legally significant consequences that remain attached to other facts.

The value of the method depends upon its capacity to expose those consequences before a legal strategy is selected.

The decisive operation is not the multiplication of analytical layers, but the reconsideration of the question to which those layers are applied.

The Situs Problem is therefore not merely a problem concerning the location of art.

It is also a problem concerning the legal significance attributed to location before the relevant legal questions have been fully identified.

The object may move. The legal question must first be properly located.

X.From Tax Planning to a Preservation Strategy

A defensible strategy begins with an inventory of the works, their ownership, provenance, current location, insurance, rights of third parties, heritage status, estimated value and relationship to the family’s broader estate.

The objectives of the owner and potential heirs must then be made explicit. Is the aim to retain the collection as a whole, pass it to one child, balance the rights of several heirs, protect an artist’s professional legacy, make the works publicly accessible, or minimise the total tax cost?

Only after establishing those objectives should the legal routes be compared. For a Flemish private collector, a registered movable gift at the ordinary 3 per cent rate may be relatively predictable. A legally effective unregistered gift may involve less immediate tax but creates a five-year fiscal risk and potential evidential issues. A collection of significant cultural importance may warrant advance examination of the Flemish payment-in-kind mechanism. A genuinely cross-border family may need a more extensive assessment of residence, situs and the different tax systems.

Madrid can matter, but putting artworks into temporary Madrid storage is not equivalent to reorganising a family’s complete legal and fiscal position. Every proposed route must be assessed for validity, overall fiscal effects, continuing control, heirs’ rights and preservation of the collection.

XI.Conclusion: The Fiscal Value and Cultural Destination of Art

The succession of art is neither solely a domestic tax question nor simply a problem of locating an object on a map. It lies at the intersection of private international law, property law, succession, taxation and cultural heritage.

Comparative law identifies at least four approaches: lifetime transmission; conditional relief in return for cultural preservation; satisfaction of tax through cultural objects; and the application of favourable personal or territorial tax regimes. Madrid’s 99 per cent relief belongs to the last category. It can be significant in qualifying cases, but it is not a general mechanism for removing Belgian-owned art from Belgian taxation.

The Belgian registration rule for qualifying foreign notarial gifts illustrates why moving an artwork does not necessarily determine the tax treatment of its transfer. The Flemish payment-in-kind scheme, by contrast, illustrates a different legislative recognition: art may have a public cultural value which the tax system takes into account through a special mechanism.

The fundamental question is therefore not exclusively where an artwork is situated, nor how to secure the lowest tax on its transmission. It is how a legal system can accommodate the several forms of value embodied in an artwork: economic wealth, family meaning, artistic creation and cultural heritage.

The movement of an artwork may change its connecting factors. It does not necessarily move the donor’s fiscal residence, the heirs’ rights or the legal consequences imposed by other jurisdictions.

A legally responsible art succession strategy begins not with the jurisdiction promising the lowest tax, but with the owner’s true objective: what is to be preserved, transferred or protected?

The object may move. Its legal consequences do not necessarily move with it.

XII.Sources, Verification Status and Outstanding Questions

A. Principal legislative and administrative materials

The following are the principal research sources to be checked in their versions applicable on the intended publication date. Listing them does not mean that every proposition above has received an independent doctrinal or professional opinion.

Belgium and Flanders

  1. Flemish Tax Code (Vlaamse Codex Fiscaliteit), including provisions on movable gift tax, inheritance tax, foreign inheritance tax and the payment-in-kind mechanism for cultural property; specifically Article 2.7.5.0.4 for relevant foreign inheritance-tax relief.
  2. Belgian Code of Registration, Mortgage and Court Registry Duties (Wetboek der registratie-, hypotheek- en griffierechten), Article 19, first paragraph, 6°, concerning qualifying foreign notarial instruments recording gifts of movables.
  3. Flemish Tax Administration: official information on the registration of gifts, ordinary gift-tax rates and the five-year risk period applicable to new unregistered donations.
  4. Flemish Government: official information on inbetalinggeving van cultuurgoederen and the applicable cultural heritage legislation.

Spain

  1. Ley 29/1987, de 18 de diciembre, del Impuesto sobre Sucesiones y Donaciones, especially Articles 6 and 7 and Disposición adicional segunda. Official consolidated legislation: https://www.boe.es/buscar/act.php?id=BOE-A-1987-28141
  2. Ley 22/2009, de 18 de diciembre, including rules concerning the autonomous communities’ tax jurisdiction and connecting factors, as applicable.
  3. Agencia Estatal de Administración Tributaria (AEAT): official guidance on taxation of gifts to nonresident beneficiaries and determination of applicable regional law.
  4. Comunidad de Madrid: official information on Donaciones, Sucesiones and the relevant 99 per cent bonificación. https://www.comunidad.madrid/atencion-contribuyente/donaciones

Other national systems

  1. Germany: Erbschaftsteuer- und Schenkungsteuergesetz, § 13(1)(2), including the detailed conditions and clawback rules for cultural property.
  2. Ireland: Revenue Commissioners, official guidance on exemption for qualifying heritage property.
  3. Netherlands: Belastingdienst, official guidance on paying inheritance tax through qualifying art.
  4. United Kingdom: HMRC, Capital Taxation and the National Heritage; Conditional Exemption; Acceptance in Lieu; and inheritance-tax rules on potentially exempt transfers and gifts with reservation.
  5. France: Code général des impôts, Article 1716 bis, and official guidance on dation en paiement.
  6. Portugal: Código do Imposto do Selo, including the exemption applicable to certain transfers to spouses, descendants and ascendants.
  7. United States: the 2026 federal estate and gift tax exclusion, with separate attention to domicile, situs and state-level taxation.

European law

  1. Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 on matters of succession, especially the exclusion of fiscal matters from its scope.
  2. Applicable European and national rules on the export and protection of cultural goods.

B. Verification register

IssueCurrent statusRequired work before final publication
Madrid’s 99% relief is a reduction of calculated tax, not 1% of market valueLegal rule; source check required at publication dateCheck current Madrid eligibility and formal requirements
Madrid five-year connecting rule for movable gifts to nonresidentsLegal rule with unresolved applicationExamine official interpretation where artworks were recently imported from abroad
Belgian registration of qualifying foreign notarial giftsLegal ruleConfirm current statutory text, connecting factors and exact formal requirements
Flemish five-year period for new unregistered giftsLegal ruleConfirm transitional and factual application
Flemish payment-in-kind mechanism and 120% creditLegal rule subject to acceptanceVerify eligibility, valuation, decision-making and treatment of foreign-held objects
Concurrent Belgian and Spanish taxationPotential consequence, case-dependentModel tax charges and relief separately for gift and succession
Spanish tax consequences for the donorOpen questionReview Spanish income-tax rules, treaty questions and any other relevant taxes
Applicable law and proprietary effects of deposited giftsOpen questionExamine Belgian and Spanish conflict rules, acceptance and delivery requirements
Treatment of an artist’s professional stock and copyrightsOpen questionAnalyse business assets, VAT, income taxation and intellectual-property succession
Comparative heritage exemptionsGeneral comparisonRecheck conditions, public-access obligations and subsequent disposal consequences in each country

C. Outstanding research questions

  1. Madrid territorial rule. How does the Spanish five-year test operate when artworks were outside Spain for a significant part of the reference period?
  2. The donor’s Spanish taxation. Can an art gift create Spanish income-tax or other fiscal consequences for the donor, in addition to taxation of the donee?
  3. Double taxation. What relief is available where Belgian and foreign gift or inheritance taxes both apply, and which restrictions distinguish gifts from successions?
  4. Proprietary transfer. Which law governs the transfer of title to artworks remaining with a third-party custodian, and how must acceptance and delivery be established?
  5. Artists’ estates. How should professional stock, unsold originals, consignment arrangements, copyright and artistic archives be valued and transmitted?
  6. Cultural preservation. Which exemptions and payment-in-kind regimes best preserve collections as a whole, and at what cost to private ownership and autonomy?

D. Research and publication notice

This working paper is an independent comparative-law research contribution, not individual legal or tax advice. It distinguishes established legal frameworks from interpretations, hypothetical assumptions and unresolved research questions. The treatment of individual transactions depends upon current legislation, binding administrative practice, the residence and status of the parties, the property involved and the formalities of transfer.

Working Paper – Research in Progress. This working paper is a publicly accessible research contribution. Certain legal interpretations and comparative tax questions remain subject to further verification, as identified in the text. It does not constitute individual legal or tax advice.

Peeters Law · Laboratorium · Working Paper II · Expanded English edition

↑