Peeters Law · Laboratorium · Working Paper II

The Situs Problem

Art Collections, Cross-Border Donations and the Legal Significance of Location

Archived editionThis is the English translation of the first edition of Working Paper II (Dutch original, revised version 2, 15 November 2026), kept unchanged for the record. It has been superseded by the expanded English edition, Art Collections, Artists’ Estates and the Limits of Fiscal Territoriality. The Dutch original of the first edition remains available at /laboratory/situs/nl/.

Peeters Law · Laboratorium · Working Paper II

THE SITUS PROBLEM

Art Collections, Cross-Border Donations and the Legal Significance of Location

The location of the artwork and the limits of the cross-border donation

Author
Karen-Anne Peeters
Series
Laboratorium | Art Law | Private International Law | Estate Planning
Status
Working paper — independent research by the author, not peer-reviewed and not published elsewhere. Original Dutch text published on 15 November 2026 (revised version 2).
Translation
Authorised English translation of the Dutch original, 15 November 2026, subject to the author's editorial approval. The translation follows revised version 2 and makes no substantive change to it.
Research cut-off
15 November 2026. The verification status of each source is stated in section 11.

This paper is an independent research contribution and does not constitute individual legal advice. Its legal analysis has not been verified in its entirety. The verification status of the legal sources and the questions requiring further research are identified in the text.

Reading guide. Every statement carries a label: Legal rule for positive law with an identifiable source; Interpretation for a reading by the author; Assumption for a factual hypothesis; Open question for a question that requires further research. Administrative guidance is identified as such and is not equated with legislation.

Translator's note. The label Legal rule identifies the source of a proposition; it does not in itself indicate that the source has been independently verified. The verification register in section 11 remains authoritative for the research status of each source. Spanish and Belgian legal terms are retained in their original language where an English equivalent could suggest a false equivalence.

1.Abstract

An artwork can be moved. The question is what travels with it. This article tests the proposition that the relocation of an artwork may change its physical situs without necessarily relocating the fiscal and legal consequences that attach to other connecting factors.

The proposition is tested against a hypothesis. A Belgian fiscal resident places a private collection in a professional storage facility in Madrid and subsequently donates it, by Spanish notarial deed, to an adult child. The question is not whether that arrangement is advantageous. The question is which connecting factors it sets in motion, and which it leaves where they are.

The inquiry leads to a differentiated answer. Under Spanish law, physical location can create taxing jurisdiction. The choice of the applicable regional regime, however, is measured against a five-year past. In addition, the residence of the donee displaces the significance of location. Under Belgian law, registration, gift tax and succession law are connected to the person of the donor and to the form of the deed. They are not connected to the location of the property. The proposition therefore holds, but in a more precise form: the law distinguishes a physical, a historical and a personal location. Only the first travels with the work.

KeywordsSitus; lex rei sitae; connecting factor; gift tax; Ley 29/1987; Disposición adicional segunda; art. 25 DLeg. 1/2010 Comunidad de Madrid; art. 19, first paragraph, 6° W.Reg.; concurrent taxation; tax abuse; Succession Regulation; movable cultural heritage.

2.The deceptive simplicity of location

Since Savigny, a legal relationship has had a seat. For tangible movable property that seat appears self-evident, for the property is always somewhere. Of all connecting factors, the lex rei sitae therefore seems the most tangible.

It is precisely this tangibility that conceals the fact that, in a single cross-border donation, the law distinguishes at least seven elements:

  1. the physical location of the artwork;
  2. the fiscal residence of the donor;
  3. the fiscal residence of the donee;
  4. the applicable Spanish regional regime;
  5. the place and legal form of the donation;
  6. the transfer of ownership;
  7. the subsequent consequences in succession law and inheritance taxation.

Each of these elements may be the decisive connecting factor for a different norm. The situs problem is therefore not the question where the work is. It is the question which norm attributes significance to which location, at which moment and for which legal consequence. The proposition stated in the abstract is a hypothesis, not a doctrinal rule. It is tested below against Spanish and Belgian law.

3.A Belgian collection in Madrid: the hypothesis

The analysis is a thought experiment, not a case file. It proceeds from the following facts.

  • AssumptionThe donor has had their fiscal residence in the Flemish Region for more than five years and retains it. The Brussels and Walloon variants are noted where they differ.
  • AssumptionThe donee is an adult child who lives in Belgium and is not a Spanish tax resident. A variant in which the child lives in Madrid is discussed separately in § 4.2.
  • AssumptionThe works belong exclusively to the donor. Questions of matrimonial property law are left aside.
  • AssumptionIn recent years the works were located in Belgium. They are moved to a storage facility in Madrid a few weeks before the donation.
  • AssumptionThe donation is recorded in a deed executed before a Spanish notary while the works are in Madrid, and it is accepted.
  • AssumptionNone of the works has been designated as protected cultural property.

4.Spanish taxation and the Madrid connecting factors

4.1 · Physical location as a basis of taxing jurisdiction

Legal ruleIn the case of a donation, the donee is the taxpayer (art. 5(b) Ley 29/1987, hereinafter LISD). A donee who is not resident in Spain is taxed por obligación real (limited, source-based tax liability) on the acquisition of property situated in Spain (art. 7 LISD). The tax accrues on the day on which the act is performed (art. 24.2 LISD). Since the amendment made by Ley 11/2021, the taxable base has been market value (art. 9 LISD). Donations between the same persons within three years are aggregated for the purpose of determining the applicable rate (art. 30 LISD).

InterpretationHere the proposition meets its first counterweight. Under Spanish law, physical location does create a legally relevant connecting factor. A work that is in Madrid on the day of the donation falls, in principle, within the scope of Spanish taxation. Without the relocation, that taxation would not exist. The statutory text lays down no minimum period of presence. Open question No administrative doctrine or case law was found on a brief presence in a storage facility, or on goods held under customs or warehousing regimes.

4.2 · The residence of the donee

Legal ruleIf the donee is resident in Spain, the donee is taxable por obligación personal (unlimited, residence-based tax liability) on all acquisitions, wherever the property is situated (art. 6 LISD). The autonomous community is then determined by the donee's place of residence (Ley 22/2009 and the five-year rule for residents in the Disposición adicional segunda, Uno.2 LISD). Only these resident taxpayers are entitled to the deduction for international double taxation under art. 23 LISD. That deduction is limited to the Spanish average rate applied to the part of the taxable base that relates to property situated abroad.

InterpretationThe residence of the donee thus changes the entire scheme. For a resident donee, the location of the work loses its significance for the choice of regime. It may nonetheless produce a counterproductive effect. If the works are in Spain, the donated property is not situated abroad, and the limit in art. 23 may restrict or exclude the deduction of Belgian gift tax. Open question This reading of art. 23 has yet to be confirmed by a Spanish tax adviser.

4.3 · Which regional regime? The five-year test

Legal ruleThe question whether Spain taxes is distinct from the question which regime governs the tax. For a non-resident donee, the competent administration is the State (return filed on modelo 651), not the autonomous community. This appears from the Agencia Tributaria's table of competences, which is administrative guidance. The statute itself provides as follows. For movable property situated in Spain that is acquired by donation, the non-resident donee may apply the regime of the community donde hayan estado situados los referidos bienes muebles un mayor número de días (“in which the said movable property has been situated for the greater number of days”). That period comprises the five years immediately preceding the accrual of the tax, counted from date to date (Disposición adicional segunda, Uno.1.e LISD). The provision is a response to the judgment of the Court of Justice of 3 September 2014, C-127/12. It was introduced by Ley 26/2014 and received its current wording through art. 4.6 Ley 11/2021, in force since 11 July 2021.

Legal ruleAccording to databases of rulings of the Dirección General de Tributos (DGT) (consultas vinculantes V0418-20, V0505-21, V0837-23 and V1515-25), the rule has been applied to money and to shares. In each case, the days that the asset had spent in different Spanish communities were compared. Open question The full texts were not checked in the official DGT database. None of these rulings concerns an asset that was situated outside Spain for the greater part of the period.

InterpretationThis is the true pivot of the hypothesis. Two readings are possible.

(a) Literal reading. The rule compares communities with one another, and days spent in Belgium fall within no community. Madrid is then the only community with any days at all, so that its regime may be applicable, even after a stay of a few weeks.

(b) Teleological reading. The rule seeks to express a lasting connection with a community. A recent arrival does not create that connection, and only the State regime then remains.

The statutory text does not exclude reading (a). Reading (b) has no express basis in it. No reliable conclusion can be drawn from the material examined. What is established is that the test measures a historical situs, not a snapshot. Moreover, the application of the regional regime is an option available to the donee. The burden of proving the number of days per community rests on whoever invokes the regime (art. 105.1 Ley 58/2003, General Tributaria).

4.4 · The Madrid bonificación: conditions

Legal ruleArt. 25.2.b of the Madrid Decreto Legislativo 1/2010 grants to groups I and II (descendants, spouse, ascendants, adopters and adoptees) a bonificación del 99 por ciento en la cuota tributaria, a relief of 99 per cent on the tax liability as calculated. Since the amendment made by Ley 2/2025, group III has received a bonificación of 50 per cent. The bonificación reduces the tax as calculated. It is not a rate of 1 per cent on the value, because the taxable base, the rate scale and the cuota are determined first.

Legal ruleSince 1 July 2025, the following conditions have applied:

  • The bonificación applies only to property that has been declared in a return filed within the voluntary filing period, or filed later but without a prior demand from the administration.
  • For property whose donation does not require a notarial deed, the donation must be recorded in a documento público (public instrument) where the taxable base exceeds €10,000. For that purpose, donations from the same donor to the same donee over a period of three years are aggregated.
  • A private document that is converted into a public instrument only after the filing period has expired confers no entitlement to the bonificación.
  • For money, the origin of the funds must be justified and stated in the deed itself.
  • Donations of up to €1,000 receive a bonificación of 100 per cent, irrespective of the degree of kinship (art. 25.2.a).

According to the official guidance, the filing period is thirty working days. The latest wording of art. 25 has been in force since 1 July 2025 and was corrected in BOCM No. 161 of 8 July 2025. Art. 25 contains no specific condition for non-residents.

InterpretationFor an art collection of any value, this means that a public instrument is required. The bonificación is, moreover, doubly conditional. First, the Madrid regime must be applicable under § 4.3. Secondly, the conditions of art. 25 itself must be satisfied. Open question Two points have not been verified: whether a foreign notarial deed, for example a Belgian one, qualifies as a documento público within the meaning of art. 25, and how the State administration assesses that regional condition in the case of non-residents.

4.5 · Consequences for the donor in Spain

Legal ruleThe donor is not a taxpayer for the purposes of Spanish gift tax. Nor is the donor among the persons who are subsidiarily liable (arts. 5 and 8 LISD). Spanish income tax law may, however, treat a donation as a disposal that gives rise to a capital gain for the donor. For non-residents, this occurs through the non-resident income tax (IRNR) where the property is situated in Spain. The double taxation convention between Belgium and Spain of 14 June 1995 (BOE 4 July 2003) nevertheless provides in art. 13(6) that gains from the alienation of property other than that referred to in paragraphs 1 to 5 sólo pueden someterse a imposición en el Estado contratante en que reside el transmitente (“may be taxed only in the Contracting State of which the alienator is a resident”).

InterpretationIf a donation is taken to be an alienation within the meaning of the convention, Spain does not levy income tax on any capital gain realised by the Belgian donor. Open question Three points have not been verified: the domestic Spanish provisions (TRLIRNR and the personal income tax act), whether treaty protection is subject to formalities, and the Belgian income tax treatment of the donation.

4.6 · Spanish anti-abuse provisions

Legal ruleThe Ley General Tributaria contains a general regime for the conflicto en la aplicación de la norma tributaria (conflict in the application of the tax rule) (art. 15) and a regime for simulation (art. 16). Open question No administrative or judicial application was found to a transfer of movable property carried out with a view to the five-year test. This article takes no position on whether such a transfer would constitute abuse. It merely observes that the question arises.

5.Belgian registration and tax consequences

5.1 · Compulsory registration

Legal ruleArt. 19, first paragraph, 6° of the Wetboek der registratie-, hypotheek- en griffierechten (Code of Registration, Mortgage and Court Fees; W.Reg.) provides that the following must be registered: de in het buitenland verleden notariële akten die titel vormen voor een schenking onder de levenden van roerende goederen door een rijksinwoner (“notarial deeds executed abroad which constitute the title for an inter vivos gift of movable property by a rijksinwoner”, that is, a resident of the Kingdom). According to the consolidated text, the provision was inserted by art. 2 of the special act of 13 December 2020, in force on 15 December 2020. The obligation rests jointly and indivisibly on the contracting parties (art. 35, 8° W.Reg., inserted by the same act). It therefore also rests on the donor. The administration set out its position in circular 2021/C/27. According to that circular, resident status (rijksinwonerschap) is assessed at the time of the deed, and gifts made by private (non-notarial) instrument fall outside the rule. Open question Three points still require confirmation in the primary text: the four-month time limit, which could not be found in the consulted version of art. 32 W.Reg.; the parallel ordinary act of 3 December 2020; and the sanction for late registration.

InterpretationThe rule is connected to two elements: the residence of the donor and the notarial form of the deed. The location of the property plays no role, and the place of the deed plays a role only because the rule must capture foreign deeds. This is where the Spanish and the Belgian rules meet. The public instrument that art. 25 DLeg. 1/2010 requires above €10,000 is precisely the kind of deed that gives rise to compulsory registration in Belgium. If a private form is chosen, the donation falls outside art. 19, 6°, but above that threshold the Madrid bonificación is then lost as well.

5.2 · Gift tax

Legal ruleGift tax is a regional tax. The competent region is the region in which the donor's fiscal domicile was established for the longest period during the five years preceding the donation (art. 5, § 2, Special Financing Act of 16 January 1989, Bijzondere Financieringswet, BFW). In the Flemish Region, the rate for movable property is 3 per cent in the direct line and between partners, and 7 per cent for all other persons (art. 2.8.4.1.1, § 2 of the Vlaamse Codex Fiscaliteit, Flemish Tax Code, VCF). According to secondary sources, the same percentages apply in the Brussels-Capital Region, and a rate of 3.3 per cent in the direct line applies in the Walloon Region. Open question The Brussels and Walloon rates have not been checked against the primary text.

5.3 · Subsequent inheritance tax

Legal ruleThe registration obligation, gift tax and inheritance tax are three separate questions. An unregistered gift of movable property is brought within inheritance tax if the donor dies within a certain period. That period is as follows:

  • Flemish Region: five years for gifts made on or after 1 January 2025, and three years for earlier gifts (official guidance of the Vlaamse Belastingdienst, the Flemish Tax Administration).
  • Brussels-Capital Region: five years for gifts made on or after 1 January 2026 (ordinance of 17 July 2025, Belgisch Staatsblad 24 July 2025, and circular 2026/C/28). Three years continue to apply to earlier gifts.
  • Walloon Region: five years since 1 January 2022, according to secondary sources.

A registered gift in principle escapes this fiction. In the hypothesis, registration is compulsory, so that this period comes into play only if the obligation is not complied with. Open question How non-compliance with art. 19, 6° relates to the inheritance tax fiction has not been examined.

5.4 · Concurrent taxation and relief

Legal ruleThe double taxation convention between Belgium and Spain applies only to taxes on income and on capital (art. 2). Gift and inheritance taxes do not fall within its scope. The Spanish deduction for international double taxation (art. 23 LISD) is available only to persons taxable por obligación personal, and therefore not to a non-resident donee.

InterpretationIn the basic hypothesis, cumulation is therefore possible: Spanish gift tax on the basis of location, and Belgian gift tax upon the compulsory registration. For neither of them has a relief rule been identified. Open question No Belgian (regional) provision was found that credits foreign gift tax. Its absence is not presented here as established.

5.5 · Belgian anti-abuse provisions

Legal ruleIn the Flemish Region, the general anti-abuse provision of art. 3.17.0.0.2 VCF has applied to registration duties, gift tax and inheritance tax since 1 January 2015. It succeeded art. 18, § 2 W.Reg. The administration bears the burden of proving the objective element of abuse. The taxpayer may show that the choice made is justified by motives other than tax considerations. Open question That art. 18, § 2 W.Reg. continues to apply in Brussels and Wallonia is an assumption that has not been verified. The question whether an anti-abuse rule would come into play in the hypothesis is not answered. It is noteworthy, however, that in the basic hypothesis Belgian taxation is not avoided by the relocation. The Belgian abuse question therefore arises less acutely than the Spanish one.

6.Ownership, custody and the legal significance of the donation

Legal ruleCustody. Under a contract of deposit (contrato de depósito, arts. 1758 et seq. Código Civil), the depositary has physical control of the work but holds it on behalf of the depositor. Moving the work into storage entails neither a transfer nor any donative intent. Storage abroad is not in itself a donation.

Legal ruleOwnership and transfer. Proprietary effects are in principle governed by the law of the place where the property is situated (art. 87 of the Belgian Code of Private International Law, WIPR; art. 10.1 Código Civil). On this point the relocation does shift the applicable law. If the work is in Madrid at the time of the transfer, Spanish property law governs the transfer. That law proceeds from the doctrine of título y modo (title and mode: a valid title together with delivery) (art. 609 Código Civil), whereas Belgian law allows ownership to pass solo consensu (Book 3 of the Civil Code). Open question Whether a Spanish donation requires a separate traditio is disputed.

Legal ruleAcceptance and obligation. Under Spanish law, a donation is perfected when the donor has knowledge of the acceptance (art. 623 Código Civil). Movable property is subject to its own formal requirements (art. 632). Interpretation The contractual aspect falls in principle under the Rome I Regulation, which, in the absence of a choice of law, refers to the law of the donor (art. 4(2), that is, the law of the country of the donor's habitual residence; as to form, art. 11). Open question How this relates to art. 10.7 Código Civil has not been examined.

InterpretationEvidence. Each question requires its own evidence:

  • for ownership: the provenance and identification of each work;
  • for the donation: the deed, the acceptance and, where applicable, the transfer of the deposit agreement;
  • for the five-year test: day-by-day transport and storage records;
  • for valuation: a market valuation that withstands scrutiny in both systems.

7.Succession law and cultural heritage

Legal ruleSuccession law. The Succession Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 excludes transfers by way of gift from its scope (art. 1(2)(g)). It does, however, subject the restoration and accounting for gifts to the law applicable to the succession (art. 23(2)(i)). That is, in principle, the law of the deceased's last habitual residence (art. 21). If the donor continues to live in Belgium, Belgian law governs any subsequent collation (inbreng) and reduction (inkorting), wherever the work may be. Since the 2017 reform (in force on 1 September 2018), the reserved portion of descendants has amounted, globally, to half of the estate. Gifts are notionally added back to the estate and are in principle valued as at the date of the gift, indexed. Open question The article numbering in Book 4 of the Civil Code has yet to be checked. Succession law (the distribution of the estate) and inheritance tax (the levy, § 5.3) remain separate.

Legal ruleCultural heritage. Works on the Flemish list of masterpieces (Topstukkenlijst) may not leave the territory without authorisation (decree of 24 January 2003). The French Community has a comparable regime (decree of 11 July 2002). Regulation (EC) No 116/2009 requires a licence for export outside the Union, not for movements between Member States. Directive 2014/60/EU governs the return of national treasures unlawfully removed. Before a Belgian court, art. 90 WIPR governs a claim for return. Interpretation Once in Spain, a work may fall under Ley 16/1985, including in respect of any later export. On this point the relocation creates new connecting factors rather than removing existing ones. Open question The articles, thresholds and time limits have yet to be verified.

8.The proposition tested: the Situs Problem through the Peeters Law method

The method does not compute an outcome. It orders the questions and makes visible that the same work has a different connecting factor in each field of law. The last column indicates whether the relocation shifts that connecting factor.

Legal questionConnecting factorDoes it move with the work?
Transfer of ownershipPhysical location at the time of transfer (art. 87 WIPR; art. 10.1 CC)Yes
Spanish taxing jurisdiction (non-resident)Physical location at the taxable event (art. 7 LISD)Yes
Spanish taxing jurisdiction (resident)Residence of the donee (art. 6 LISD)No
Spanish regional regimeHistorical location over five years (DA 2ª LISD)Uncertain
Madrid bonificaciónRegime + form + timely return (art. 25.2 DLeg. 1/2010)Not by location alone
Belgian registration obligationResident donor (rijksinwoner) + notarial deed (art. 19, 6° W.Reg.)No
Competent Belgian regionFiscal residence of the donor (art. 5 BFW)No
Collation and reductionLast habitual residence (arts. 21, 23 Succession Regulation)No
Heritage protectionProtection status and locationCreates new connecting factors
T
Territorial context. Three legal orders are involved, each with its own internal levels: the Spanish State and its communities, and the Belgian federal authority with its regions and communities. Territory, moreover, operates in time. The Spanish regional test looks back five years, as does the Belgian regional test. A territorial connection is therefore not a point but a trajectory.
M
Substantive fields of law. Property law, the law of obligations, gift and income taxation, succession law and heritage law presuppose one another. Gift tax arises only on a donation that exists in civil law. A donation exists only once the rules of form and acceptance of the applicable law have been observed.
N
Normative structure. The Spanish regime is a response to EU law (C-127/12). The regional bonificación operates only within the framework of the national statute. Belgian fiscal federalism distributes registration and taxation across different normative levels. Treaty law covers income tax, not gift tax. What one layer alleviates, the other leaves untouched.
C
Language and legal culture. Bonificación en la cuota is not a rate. Situado does not mean “habitually present”. Documento público and notariële akte (notarial deed) overlap, but each has its own function within its system. Título y modo and consensual transfer, likewise, read the same delivery differently. Whoever equates concepts silently shifts the applicable law.
S
Strategy. The strategic dimension asks first about the family or patrimonial objective, and only then about the instrument. Relying on a single connecting factor does not make the others disappear. It may even create new ones: a second taxing jurisdiction, a Spanish heritage regime and a burden of proof measured day by day.
Σ
The Heyvaertian fault line. The fault line runs in two places. Between the physical and the historical situs: the relocation does create Spanish taxing jurisdiction, but it does not rewrite the past that the five-year test measures. And between form and consequence: the public instrument that the Madrid bonificación requires above €10,000 is the same deed that gives rise to the Belgian registration obligation. The relocation moves the property, not the donor.
Ω
Reflexive observation. The question “where is the work?” suggests that location is a fact from which the law follows. The reverse is more accurate: each norm itself determines which fact it treats as location, and at what moment. The proposition of this article is therefore itself open to criticism. It describes a structure, but it does not prove that Spanish law will reject the literal reading set out in § 4.3. Whoever infers a tax consequence from the relocation, or its absence, makes the leap from fact to norm that the method seeks to expose.

9.Provisional conclusions

  1. Under Belgian law, the proposition holds. The registration obligation, the competent region, gift tax and succession law are connected to the donor and to the form of the deed. No Belgian rule was found under which the relocation undoes these consequences.
  2. Under Spanish law, it holds in a modified form. Physical location creates taxing jurisdiction in respect of a non-resident donee. The relocation therefore does not merely shift those consequences; it may create new ones.
  3. Whether the Madrid regime becomes applicable depends on a five-year test whose application to property previously situated abroad is uncertain. Even then, the 99 per cent bonificación is a reduction of the tax as calculated and not a rate of 1 per cent. It presupposes a public instrument and a timely return.
  4. Concurrent Spanish and Belgian gift tax is possible in the basic hypothesis. No treaty-based or domestic relief was identified.
  5. Storage is not a donation. Only in respect of the transfer of ownership does the relocation shift the applicable law.

The more precise proposition therefore reads as follows. The relocation of an artwork changes its physical situs. As a result, connecting factors that attach to that physical location may arise. The consequences that the law attaches to a historical location or to the person of the donor are not relocated by it. Where the statute or the facts provide no certainty, the conclusion remains open.

10.What remains legally unresolved?

Questions for further doctrinal research or for confirmation by a qualified Spanish tax adviser

  1. The five-year test where the property was previously abroad. Do days outside Spain count? Is reading (a) or reading (b) in § 4.3 the correct one? The full DGT rulings and the case law must be examined. Spanish tax adviser.
  2. Brief presence. Is an asset that is briefly held in a storage facility or under a customs regime “situado en territorio español” within the meaning of art. 7 LISD? Spanish tax adviser.
  3. Public instrument. Does a foreign notarial deed satisfy art. 25.2.b DLeg. 1/2010? How does the State assess that regional condition in the case of non-residents? Spanish tax adviser.
  4. Art. 23 LISD for a resident donee. Does the location of the works in Spain restrict the deduction of Belgian gift tax? Spanish tax adviser.
  5. Anti-abuse. Can art. 15 or 16 LGT, art. 3.17.0.0.2 VCF or art. 18, § 2 W.Reg. be applied to a transfer made with a view to the five-year test? Doctrinal research and Spanish tax adviser.
  6. Relief from double taxation. Does any of the three regions have a rule that credits foreign gift tax? Doctrinal research.
  7. Consequences for the donor. What does domestic Spanish law (TRLIRNR and the personal income tax act) provide on a capital gain arising on a donation? Does the donation fall under art. 13(6) of the convention, and which formalities apply? How does Belgian income tax treat the donation? Spanish tax adviser and doctrinal research.
  8. Belgian registration. Must the four-month time limit, the sanction for non-registration and the relationship with the ordinary act of 3 December 2020 still be confirmed? Which rates and anti-abuse rules apply in Brussels and Wallonia? Doctrinal research.
  9. Property law. Does the Spanish donation require traditio? How do art. 10.7 Código Civil and the Rome I Regulation relate to one another? Doctrinal research.
  10. Heritage and valuation. Which provisions of Ley 16/1985 become relevant once a work has entered Spain? How is market value proven in both systems? Doctrinal research and experts.

11.Legal sources

Verification status as at 15 November 2026

Primary source examined checked in an official or consolidated statutory text; Official administrative guidance administrative explanation, not legislation; Secondary source confirmed through a secondary account; Not verified in this version not checked for this version.

A · Spain

  1. Primary source examinedLey 29/1987, de 18 de diciembre, del Impuesto sobre Sucesiones y Donaciones, arts. 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 23, 24.2, 30 and Disposición adicional segunda, Uno.1.e and Uno.2 (version of the DA 2ª in force since 11 July 2021; latest consolidated update of the act: 28 December 2022). BOE-A-1987-28141
  2. Primary source examinedDecreto Legislativo 1/2010, de 21 de octubre, de la Comunidad de Madrid, art. 25 (as amended by Ley 6/2018, Ley 7/2022 and Ley 2/2025, in force since 1 July 2025; correction BOCM No. 161, 8 July 2025; consolidated version of 10 July 2026). BOCM-m-2010-90068
  3. Official administrative guidanceAgencia Tributaria, Modelo 651, Cuadro de delimitación de competencias y normativa aplicable. agenciatributaria.gob.es
  4. Official administrative guidanceComunidad de Madrid, Donaciones. comunidad.madrid
  5. Secondary sourceDGT, consultas vinculantes V0418-20 (21 February 2020), V0505-21 (5 March 2021), V0837-23 (11 April 2023) and V1515-25 (19 August 2025), as reproduced in databases. The full text has yet to be checked in the official DGT database.
  6. Secondary sourceConvention between Belgium and Spain for the avoidance of double taxation, Brussels, 14 June 1995 (BOE No. 159, 4 July 2003), arts. 2 and 13(6). Consulted via a reproduction of the BOE text.
  7. Not verified in this versionLey 22/2009, arts. 28 and 32; Ley 58/2003 General Tributaria, arts. 15, 16 and 105.1; RDLeg. 5/2004 (TRLIRNR) and Ley 35/2006 (IRPF) on capital gains; Código Civil, arts. 10.1, 10.7, 609, 623, 632 and 1758 et seq.; Ley 16/1985 del Patrimonio Histórico Español.

B · Belgium

  1. Primary source examinedWetboek der registratie-, hypotheek- en griffierechten, art. 19, first paragraph, 6° and second paragraph, and art. 35, 8°, inserted or replaced by the special act of 13 December 2020, arts. 2 and 3, in force on 15 December 2020 (consolidated version, Codex Vlaanderen). codex.vlaanderen.be
  2. Secondary sourceCircular 2021/C/27 concerning the act of 3 December 2020 and the special act of 13 December 2020. The four-month time limit has yet to be confirmed (art. 32 W.Reg.).
  3. Primary source examinedVlaamse Codex Fiscaliteit, art. 2.8.4.1.1, § 2 (rate) and art. 3.17.0.0.2 (anti-abuse). codex.vlaanderen.be
  4. Official administrative guidanceVlaamse Belastingdienst, Registratie van een schenking (Registration of a gift), stating the five-year period for gifts made on or after 1 January 2025. vlaanderen.be
  5. Secondary sourceOrdinance of the Brussels-Capital Region of 17 July 2025 (Belgisch Staatsblad 24 July 2025) and circular 2026/C/28. Walloon Region: rate of 3.3 per cent and five-year period since 1 January 2022.
  6. Not verified in this versionSpecial act of 16 January 1989, art. 5, § 2; WIPR, arts. 87 and 90; Civil Code (Burgerlijk Wetboek), Book 3 and Book 4; act of 31 July 2017; decree of 24 January 2003 (Flemish Community); décret du 11 juillet 2002 (French Community); art. 18, § 2 W.Reg. for Brussels and Wallonia.

C · European Union

  1. Secondary sourceCJEU, 3 September 2014, C-127/12, Commission v Spain, ECLI:EU:C:2014:2130. Cited in the DA 2ª LISD and in the AEAT table of competences.
  2. Not verified in this versionRegulation (EC) No 593/2008 (Rome I), arts. 4(2) and 11; Regulation (EU) No 650/2012, arts. 1(2)(g), 21 and 23(2)(i); Regulation (EC) No 116/2009; Directive 2014/60/EU. These provisions are cited on the basis of their known content but were not re-examined for this version.

Legal disclaimer

This contribution is a research contribution and not individual legal advice. It has not been legally verified in its entirety: the verification status of each source is stated in section 11. It does not claim that a Belgian collector obtains the Madrid regime by moving artworks to Spain. Nor does it claim that storage abroad excludes Belgian tax, or that it produces a saving.

This English text is a translation. The Dutch original, De plaats van het kunstwerk en de grenzen van de grensoverschrijdende schenking, prevails in the event of any divergence.

↑